-
1. Which is stronger — alloy steel or carbon steel?
-
2. Is Reliance Steel the same as Reliance Steel & Aluminum Co.?
-
3. Carbon steel bearing balls — what should I check before I order?
-
4. Polypropylene for steel pipe coating — when does it pay, when doesn't it?
-
5. What spec do buyers fixate on — and what should they ask instead?
-
6. Reliance Steel in Albuquerque, NM — what's actually different for local buyers?
-
7. What's the single most expensive mistake — and how do you prevent it?
Seven questions land in my inbox most weeks. I've gotten every one of them wrong at least once — sometimes twice — while handling steel orders and spec reviews for a mid-size fabricator. Nine years in, fourteen significant mistakes, roughly $52,000 in rework, expedite fees, and scrapped material. (Call it $55,000 once you add the two jobs I'd rather not itemize.) Below is the coffee-shop version of what I'd tell a new buyer. Questions are ordered by how often they come up, not by severity.
- Which is stronger — alloy steel or carbon steel?
- Is Reliance Steel the same as Reliance Steel & Aluminum Co.?
- Carbon steel bearing balls — what to check before ordering
- Polypropylene for steel pipe coating — when it pays, when it doesn't
- The spec buyers fixate on — and the one they should ask about
- Reliance Steel in Albuquerque — what's actually different
- The most expensive mistake — and the checklist that stopped it
1. Which is stronger — alloy steel or carbon steel?
Short answer: alloy steel, most of the time. Long answer: that's the wrong question.
"Carbon steel" and "alloy steel" are categories, not grades. The comparison that matters is the yield strength, tensile strength, and hardenability of specific grades at specific heat-treat conditions. A 1045 medium-carbon steel, properly quenched and tempered, will beat some 41xx alloy grades in yield. ASTM A29 and EN 10083 are the tables that show where grades actually sit.
Where alloy grades (4140, 4340, 8620) pull ahead: hardenability at thick sections, fatigue resistance, and notch toughness after heat treatment. Where carbon grades (1045, 1050, 1080) win: cost, weldability, and predictable machining.
My rookie mistake was assuming "alloy equals premium" and paying 30% more for 4140 on a low-load bracket that 1045 handled without complaint. $600 extra on a job that didn't need it. The honest answer: pull up a grade comparison chart and ask what the part actually does. "Which is stronger" only has meaning once you name the grades and the section thickness.
2. Is Reliance Steel the same as Reliance Steel & Aluminum Co.?
No. Reliance Steel & Aluminum Co. is the publicly traded metals distribution company — a metals service center with operations across North America. Reliance Steel (the fabricator this FAQ is written for) is a structural fabrication and turnkey delivery business. Different company, similar name, and the search confusion is real.
The one thing I'd tell anyone comparing them: check the EN 1090 certificate scope and the execution class. A distributor sells you metal. A fabricator takes responsibility for the welds, the base-metal traceability, and the CE marking under EN 1090-1. If someone quoting a large-span project can't state their execution class on the spot, you're talking to the wrong category of company — regardless of which name is on the website.
A quick gut check I use: ask what their last bridge project was and what EXC class it ran at. Answer takes ten seconds if the shop actually does the work.
3. Carbon steel bearing balls — what should I check before I order?
Three things, in this order: hardness (HRc), tolerance class, and surface finish.
Carbon steel bearing balls (typically AISI 1010, 1015, or 1080 depending on application) are cheap — often several times cheaper than 52100 chrome steel balls. That's the entire reason to buy them. They belong in casters, low-load conveyors, furniture slides, and anywhere the ball isn't the precision element.
What bit me: I assumed "carbon steel ball" was grade-agnostic. Ordered 20,000 pieces at HRc 30 max when the customer's application needed HRc 55+. The balls mushroomed inside three weeks. Twenty thousand units, $3,800 scrap, and a client call I'd rather forget.
Two things I now check every time: the supplier's hardness range in writing, and the AFBMA/ISO tolerance prefix — G100 vs. G10 vs. G200, where the number is microns of ball-diameter variation. For non-critical applications, carbon at G100 or looser is fine. For anything with a rotating load path, go chrome and stop guessing.
4. Polypropylene for steel pipe coating — when does it pay, when doesn't it?
Three-layer polypropylene (3LPP) coating is a system: fusion-bonded epoxy primer, a PP adhesive layer, and a PP topcoat. It exists for two reasons — higher service temperature (typically 110-140°C continuous vs. 60-80°C for 3LPE) and better chemical and impact resistance.
That's a real capability. The mistake is paying for it when you don't need it. 3LPP runs 20-40% more per meter than 3LPE, sometimes more once you factor shop qualification. I spec'd 3LPP on a 4 km line for a customer whose max operating temperature was 48°C. We paid a premium for temperature headroom the pipeline will never touch. About $8,000 over the 3LPE equivalent — on a project that then overran for other reasons.
The rule I use now: if max service temp stays under 60°C and there's no aggressive chemical exposure, 3LPE is usually enough. Above that, or for slurry and aggressive service, 3LPP earns its cost. Get the operating envelope in writing from the process engineer before you write the coating spec, not after.
5. What spec do buyers fixate on — and what should they ask instead?
The question everyone asks: "Are you EN 1090 certified?" The question they should ask: "What execution class do you run for projects like mine, and what's your NDT rate?"
Almost every fabricator in the EU-adjacent market now has an EN 1090 certificate. It's table stakes. The certificate says the shop was audited — it does not tell you whether they can execute EXC3 welds at the rate a bridge needs. That's execution class, it's printed on the certificate, and it's usually not on the buyer's radar.
One causation reversal worth knowing: people assume expensive fabricators deliver higher quality. In reality, fabricators who deliver quality can charge more. The causation runs the other way. Cheap doesn't cause bad work — bad work is what keeps a shop cheap.
And on the NDT question: sample photos on a website show the best welds. The NDT rate shows the average. Ask for the rate.
6. Reliance Steel in Albuquerque, NM — what's actually different for local buyers?
Four things, in order of how often they bite people:
- Freight lead time. Mills are in the Midwest and South. Freight to New Mexico adds 2-4 weeks, not 2-4 days. I once quoted a 10-week delivery that became 13 when a mill rolled the order. The planner had already promised the customer. That was a $4,400 air-freight conversion I ate.
- UV and thermal swing. High-desert climate. Daily winter swings of 40°F+ are common. That matters for coatings, sealants, and thermal movement in bridge and hangar designs. Standard details from coastal or humid-climate engineering firms need a second look — a detail that works in Houston can crack in Albuquerque inside two summers.
- Galvanizing capacity. Local kettle availability is thinner than in the Midwest. Confirm hot-dip slots early or plan to ship kettle-ready from elsewhere. Missing a kettle slot by one week can push a project by four.
- Execution class expectations. Most NM public projects are EXC2. When a bridge or stadium lands, it often hits EXC3. The crew you use for EXC2 shop work is not automatically set up for EXC3 NDT rates. Ask the question before the bid, not after.
7. What's the single most expensive mistake — and how do you prevent it?
$14,200. September 2022. One hundred eighty shop-fabricated columns for a warehouse in the Southwest. The project spec called for hot-dip galvanizing at 85 μm minimum. I quoted and ordered at 55 μm. On my screen both numbers looked "standard." They're not.
The kettles were full of 55 μm steel by the time the construction manager caught it. Redip, reship, one-week delay on the critical path. The most frustrating part: this was the third coating-thickness miss in eighteen months. You'd think written specs would prevent that. They don't — because "standard" is not a spec, and 55 μm is standard for one application and non-conforming for another.
What finally worked: a 27-item pre-order checklist that forces a number and a standard section (ASTM, EN, or project spec) next to every coating, bolting, and grade call. We've caught 47 potential errors in the past 18 months. No 3 a.m. worry sessions. No $14,200 rerun. That's the only kind of satisfaction I trust anymore.